CHAPTER 5:
UNDERSTANDING YOUTH AND DIGITAL MEDIA
This
chapter basically challenges teachers and other adults to re-evaluate the way
they consider young people and how they learn/interact with technology. The author
discusses the many ways that the youth of today are actually still very much
like the youth of yesterday, they just happen to communicate their angst by way
of different forms of technology. Something of interest that the author
discusses is the effort put into texting, which is a huge form of communication
amongst young people. She proposes that even though many text and instant
messages composed by the younger generation appear sloppy and almost without
any thought, are actually very controlled contributions so as not to seem
vulnerable to their peers. Later in the chapter, some examples of how the media
sources students use most can be used to engage them in learning.
I have to be honest; it is
difficult for me to see kids on cell phones constantly. I am open-minded enough
to realize that yes they can be beneficial—I really did like the way the
teacher used email and instant messaging as ways for her students to interact
about literature. I did find this chapter interesting in that I had not thought
about the way students spend their time texting and IMing today, really is
similar to how my younger sister used to spend two hours or more at a time on
the phone talking about really nothing. I guess my struggle is that, yes they
are communicating and that’s great but are they forgetting how to speak to
others and hold meaningful conversations? A lot of the verbal cues are lost
when you cannot hear how someone says something. Emoticons cannot replace true
emotion. I suppose, as I observe others out in the world on their phones, I am
always curious about whether we are losing touch with one another even though
we are more connected than we have ever been. (An example of this—I eat out a
lot and enjoy watching people. I can’t count the times I have been in a
restaurant and observed a couple sitting at a table where they are both on
their cell phones texting others. I assume they are texting others, it would be
really sad if they were sitting across from one another and texting each other
instead of talking. So what I see, is that people are present, but they are not
there with you, they are not engaged.)
I have the same feeling that you felt, because when I got my first cell phone I was age 15, and by that time texting was not really popular, people would still talk in person to do the communication. But we must accept this change that students can get benefits from texting and IMing in today's world.
ReplyDeleteTrue, Tommy. Acceptance of change is necessary, just not always easy....
DeleteI totally agree. One of my biggest annoyances is seeing children at a table with their parents on a mobile device. I'm not a parent, but goodness that bugs me! I think as teachers though, we have to have these conversations with our students--face to face--about socially acceptable behavior. Texting is awesome, and I do it quite a bit. I remember when I started texting and it was the most amazing thing ever. I think it really helps students who are shy or self conscience express themselves. Texting in a classroom can be a scaffolding technique to start students participating in verbal discussions. Maybe let them start having discussions online or via text, and the next time let them do that a little less, and then even less until they are comfortabel having verbal discussions. I think it can be a great tool, if it is implemented in a way that helps students progress in discussions or other interactions.
ReplyDeletePatsy, I like the idea of gradually progressing the amount of texting/discussion participation. I hadn't thought of that but it would be good technique for getting them comfortable.
Delete